Which Trade Should I Make??

[blooge]

I have a choice between two trades. Which one you you make?

Trade 1: I give Anquan Boldin to get Marshawn Lynch
Trade 2: I give Joey Galloway to get Willis McGahee

My other WRs are: Reggie Wayne, Javon Walker, Shaun McDonald, Santana Moss, Jacoby Jones.

My other RBs are: Joseph Addai, Rudi Johnson, Sammy Morris, DeShawn Wynn

As you can see, I really need another running back. Which trade is best?

[swatt007]

I actually like the RBs you do have in your team, but now you need to keep an eye on R Johnsons injury during the week. Boldin and galloway are both about the same caliber players so that part of your offers shouldn't be the diciding factor. Make your decision based on the RB capabilities. Between Lynch and McGahee i would go with McGahee because he has better matchups in coming weeks.

[Ford Fairlane]

I would go for the Galloway for McGahee trade since I like better what you've giving up and what you're getting.

Boldin seems to be succeeding more in Ken Whisenhunt's new offense, and if Warner gets the full-time gig, Boldin's his guy.

McGahee isn't as dynamic as Lynch, but he's definitely on a better team that will likely late leads more often. Also, since Lynch is a rookie, you never know when he'll hit the wall in his first 16 game season.

[raiders70]

I would also say go for the Galloway for McGahee trade since you are not giving up much. Lynch is a nice player but with him being the only offence that buffalo provides then it wont be long before defenses start piling up on him.

Good Luck